Writers of the West

Self-Publishing vs Traditional Publishing: What You Need to Know

Self-Publishing vs Traditional Publishing: What You Need to Know

Introduction: The Evolving World of Book Publishing

Publishing a book used to be like applying for an exclusive club membership—lots of effort, little reward, and no guarantees. 

Traditional publishers were the gatekeepers, and their criteria for entry? Mysterious, to say the least. Many brilliant manuscripts ended up in the dreaded “slush pile,” never seeing the light of day.

But things started to shift in the late 2000s. The rise of digital publishing platforms gave authors direct access to their readers. No more groveling for a publishing deal. 

Self-publishing became the hero of the underdogs, offering everyone a shot. Today, platforms like Amazon Kindle Direct Publishing (KDP) and IngramSpark have revolutionized the industry, turning it into a playground for writers with ambition.

According to recent studies, the self-publishing industry has grown by over 264% in the past decade. Platforms like Amazon Kindle Direct Publishing now dominate the market, with millions of titles published yearly. 

This shift reflects changing reader habits, with more people seeking diverse voices that traditional publishers often overlook.”

Here’s the kicker: self-publishing isn’t just a backup plan anymore—it’s the first choice for thousands of authors. Stats show that the self-publishing market is expected to grow by billions in the next decade. Readers don’t care if your book came from a big publishing house or your laptop. They care about your story.

What does this mean for you? Freedom. Flexibility. And a real shot at success without the middleman.

Authors today have a choice: wait for the approval of traditional gatekeepers or take charge of their careers with self-publishing.”

What is Self-Publishing?

What Does It Mean to Self-Publish a Book?

Self-publishing is like hosting your own party instead of waiting for an invite. You’re the boss—from writing and editing to designing the cover and deciding how much to charge.

Here’s how it works: once your manuscript is ready, you upload it to a platform like Amazon Kindle Direct Publishing or IngramSpark. These platforms handle the heavy lifting—printing, distribution, and even digital formats for e-books. You get to choose where your book is sold and even set the price. 

Platforms like Amazon KDP let you publish both e-books and print-on-demand paperbacks, while IngramSpark offers global distribution, even to brick-and-mortar stores. Other platforms, such as Draft2Digital, handle distribution to multiple online retailers, simplifying the process.”

Royalties and Earnings in Self-Publishing

Let’s talk about royalties. In traditional publishing, you’re lucky to see 10%. With self-publishing, you can pocket up to 70%. That’s a massive difference.

Don’t worry about quality either. Today’s tools make it easy to create a professional-looking book. Want proof? Think of authors like Andy Weir (The Martian), who started as self-published and became a household name. Self-publishing isn’t a risk—it’s an opportunity.

What is Traditional Publishing?

Traditional publishing is the classic route to getting your book on bookstore shelves. It’s like auditioning for Broadway—you write your manuscript, submit it to literary agents or publishers, and wait (sometimes forever) for a callback. If they say “yes,” congratulations! You’ve signed up for a partnership where they handle publishing logistics, like editing, design, and distribution.

But here’s the catch: it’s not all smooth sailing. First, you need an agent to even pitch your book to a publisher. Agents filter through piles of manuscripts daily, and only a fraction get through. If you clear this hurdle, the publisher takes control. That means you’ll have limited say in decisions like cover design, pricing, and even content changes.

“Take John Doe, an aspiring author who spent five years pitching to publishers before finally landing a deal. By the time his book was published, the content felt outdated, and he struggled to regain momentum.”

The process can take months—or years. From landing a deal to seeing your book in print, patience isn’t just a virtue; it’s mandatory. Authors often have to compromise their creative vision to meet market trends or publisher preferences.

Why do people still choose traditional publishing? Credibility. It’s the gold star that says, “I made it!” Plus, traditional publishers offer access to professional editing, design, and a wide distribution network. For some, that’s worth the wait.

But in today’s fast-paced world, many authors are realizing they don’t need a gatekeeper to share their stories. Self-publishing skips the red tape and lets you decide how your book reaches readers.

“Interestingly, even traditional publishers are now adopting strategies from self-publishing to keep up with digital-first readers.”

Why Self-Publishing Outshines Traditional Publishing

Let’s face it: self-publishing is the Beyoncé of the publishing world—powerful, independent, and totally in control. It’s not just about skipping the publisher; it’s about owning the entire process.

Key Advantages of Self-Publishing

Self-publishing gives authors more creative control, higher royalties, and faster time to market. Authors can publish without waiting for a traditional publisher’s approval and keep a larger share of their book’s profits.

Creative Control:

You’re the boss. Your book, your rules. Want a purple unicorn on the cover? Done. Prefer a quirky chapter title? Go for it.   “Traditional publishers often require significant changes to align with market trends. For example, authors have reported being asked to rewrite endings or add romance subplots to increase sales potential.”

Higher Royalties:

Traditional publishers offer royalties of 10-15%. Self-publishing? You keep up to 70%. That’s math you can’t ignore. “Imagine earning $2.80 on a $4.00 e-book sale through self-publishing compared to just $0.40 through traditional publishing. The math speaks for itself.”

Speed to Market:

Traditional publishing can take years. With self-publishing, you could write, edit, and publish your book in months—or even weeks.

Accessibility of All:

Anyone can self-publish. There are no rejection letters or gatekeepers, just a clear path to sharing your story with the world.

But the real kicker? Self-publishing isn’t just for “hobby” writers. Bestselling authors like E.L. James (Fifty Shades of Grey) and Amanda Hocking (Trylle Trilogy) started here. They didn’t wait for approval—they made it happen.

Self-publishing gives you the freedom to turn your passion into profit without sacrificing your vision. In a world where readers value authenticity, it’s clear why more authors are embracing this approach.

The Limitations of Traditional Publishing

Traditional publishing might seem like the golden ticket, but it’s not all glitz and glam. Behind the scenes, the process can be a frustrating labyrinth.

The Waiting Game:

Getting a publisher’s approval feels like waiting for a text back from your crush—anxious and endless. From querying agents to pitching publishers, the entire process can take years. Even after you get a deal, the timeline from acceptance to publication is often 18 months or more.

Earnings Problem:

Most authors earn a royalty rate of 10-15%, which is peanuts compared to the effort you put in. Oh, and those advance payments you hear about? They sound exciting but often come with strings attached—like meeting tight deadlines or sales benchmarks.

Creative Freedom? Not so much. 

Once you sign that contract, the publisher gets a big say in your book. From cover design to marketing strategy, their preferences take priority. Imagine writing your dream novel only to have its title changed because “focus groups liked something else better.” Ouch.

Timeline

The average timeline for traditionally published books is 18-24 months. This delay can mean missing out on trends or timeliness in your content.

Rejection:

“Did you know that more than 90% of manuscripts submitted to traditional publishers are rejected? For first-time authors, the odds are even slimmer.”

Difficulty:

Lastly, traditional publishing isn’t as accessible as it seems. Breaking into the industry is tough, especially for new or niche writers. Publishers often prioritize “safe” projects over innovative ideas, which leaves many authors feeling overlooked.

The bottom line? Traditional publishing comes with its perks, but the trade-offs—long waits, low pay, and limited control—make it less appealing for many modern authors.

Debunking Myths About Self-Publishing

Let’s bust some myths because self-publishing gets a bad rap it doesn’t deserve. Spoiler alert: these myths? Totally outdated.

Myth 1: Self-Published Books Are Low Quality

Not anymore! With professional editing and design services widely available, self-published books can look just as polished as traditionally published ones. Plus, readers care more about compelling stories than fancy logos on the spine.

Myth 2: Self-Publishing Is Expensive

Sure, there are upfront costs like editing, cover design, and formatting, but they’re investments in your book’s success. Plus, you’re not splitting profits with a publisher, so you’ll see a higher return on every sale.

Myth 3: You Can’t Market a Self-Published Book

False! Social media, author websites, and platforms like Amazon offer incredible marketing opportunities. Many self-published authors build loyal fan bases online without relying on traditional methods. Many self-published authors leverage platforms like Instagram and TikTok to build communities. The rise of #BookTok has turned self-published books into viral sensations.

Myth 4: It isn’t Affordable

Budget-friendly tools like Canva for cover design and Grammarly for editing mean you don’t need to break the bank to self-publish.


Myth 5: Self-publishing is only for amateurs

Think again. Bestselling authors like Andy Weir (The Martian) and E.L. James (Fifty Shades of Grey) started self-publishing. It’s not about the method—it’s about the story.

Self-publishing gives you the tools to succeed on your terms. Don’t let these outdated myths hold you back from sharing your story with the world.

When Self-Publishing Is the Right Choice for You

So, how do you know if self-publishing is your perfect match? Spoiler: It’s not just for aspiring authors. Let’s explore when this route makes the most sense.

  1. You Value Creative Freedom: If the thought of someone else dictating your story gives you hives, self-publishing is for you. It’s ideal for authors who want complete control over their work, from the first draft to the finished product.
  2. You Have a Niche Audience: Writing a sci-fi Western romance or a cookbook for mushroom lovers? Traditional publishers might not see the potential, but self-publishing lets you reach niche readers who’ll love your unique angle.
  3. You’re Comfortable With DIY (or Delegating): While self-publishing puts you in charge, it doesn’t mean doing everything alone. Editing, cover design, and marketing can be outsourced to pros who know the game.
  4. You Want Faster Results: If you have a timely story or just hate waiting (who doesn’t?), self-publishing skips the lengthy submission and approval process. Your book can hit shelves in weeks, not years.
  5. You’re Building a Brand: Self-publishing isn’t just about one book. For bloggers, influencers, or entrepreneurs, it’s a way to establish authority and connect with a loyal audience.

Self-publishing is also ideal if you have a memoir or a personal project that doesn’t fit neatly into traditional genres. These stories often resonate deeply with niche audiences.

Self-publishing is the ultimate choice for writers who value independence, creative control, and quick results. If that sounds like you, it might just be the perfect fit.

How to Succeed as a Self-Published Author

Okay, so you’ve decided to self-publish—great choice! But now what? Success in self-publishing isn’t about luck; it’s about strategy. Here’s how you can crush it:

  1. Write for Your Audience: It’s tempting to write your dream story, but ask yourself—who’s going to read it? Identify your target audience and create something they’ll love. Writing for a niche can actually be your biggest advantage.
  2. Nail the Editing and Design: A typo or an ugly cover is the fastest way to lose readers. Hire a professional editor and cover designer to give your book the polish it deserves. Remember, you’re competing with traditionally published books, so quality matters.
  3. Master Marketing: Self-publishing means you’re also the marketing department. Use social media, email newsletters, and author websites to build buzz. Platforms like Amazon also let you run ads to reach potential readers.
  4. Network Like a Pro: Connect with other authors, join writing groups, and share tips. The self-publishing community is full of people ready to help. Plus, collaborations (like cross-promotions) can boost your visibility.
  5. Think Long-Term: Success doesn’t happen overnight. Focus on building a brand, whether that’s writing more books, starting a blog, or engaging with readers on platforms like Goodreads.
  6. Reader Reviews: Encourage early readers to leave reviews on platforms like Amazon and Goodreads. Positive reviews significantly boost a book’s visibility.
  7. Marketing Strategies: Experiment with promotional pricing, like offering the e-book for free during launch week to build momentum. This strategy often leads to higher rankings and more long-term sales.

Self-publishing success is about patience, planning, and persistence. Follow these steps, and you’ll be well on your way to bestseller status.

Conclusion: Why Self-Publishing Is the Future

Self-publishing isn’t just an alternative—it’s the future. It’s about freedom, control, and getting your book out there without waiting for someone else to “approve” it.

Sure, traditional publishing has its perks, but the long waits, low royalties, and limited creative input aren’t for everyone. Self-publishing puts power back into your hands. It’s your story, your vision, and your rewards.

Whether you’re writing your first book or your fiftieth, self-publishing is the way to reach readers directly, build your brand, and truly own your success. The tools are there, the opportunities are endless, and the only thing left to do? Start.

If you need help with book self publishing services, or you only require Amazon KDP Book publishing services, Contact us today.


Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

  1. Is self-publishing only for first-time authors? Not at all! While self-publishing is a popular choice for first-time authors, many seasoned writers use it to retain creative control and earn higher royalties. Even traditionally published authors often turn to self-publishing for specific projects.
  1. Do self-published books sell as well as traditionally published ones? Absolutely. Many self-published books have become bestsellers. It all depends on your marketing strategy, audience engagement, and the quality of your book. Success stories like The Martian by Andy Weir prove that self-publishing can compete with traditional publishing.
  1. How much does it cost to self-publish a book? The cost can vary, but it generally includes expenses for editing, cover design, formatting, and marketing. On average, self-published authors invest anywhere from $500 to $3,000, depending on their needs and goals.
  1. What platforms are best for self-publishing? Popular platforms include Amazon Kindle Direct Publishing (KDP), IngramSpark, and Draft2Digital. Each platform has its strengths, so it’s important to choose based on your goals, like global distribution or print-on-demand options.
  2. Can self-published authors win awards or gain industry recognition? Yes! Many self-published books have won prestigious awards and received critical acclaim. With the rise of self-publishing, more award programs now recognize independently published works.
Hosanna Flores

Hosanna Flores

Senior book Editor at Writers of the West with over a decade of experience in ghostwriting best selling self-help and children's book.

Related Blogs
section divider